Tell us
what you really want
from your fertility clinic abroad…
Complete a 5-minute, anonymous survey to help others find the right clinic abroad, and we'll donate €1 to a fertility society for each submission.

Can PGS / PGT-A – embryo genetic diagnosis increase the IVF success rates?

8 fertility expert(s) answered this question

Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Aneuploidy (PGT-A) – PGS – what is it? Does PGS influence IVF success rates?

What is PGS/ PGT-A? Why is it used and why one may be advised to use it in IVF treatment? What does embryo genetic testing look like? What are the pros and cons of this procedure?

Thinking about IVF treatment abroad?
We help you choose the right clinic - and the right doctor for your case. Free.
I’m Olympe, your Patient Advocate. Let’s connect!
Answer from the fertility expert:
Dr Alper Eraslan, Obstetrics & Gynaecology Surgeon; IVF Specialist, Cyprus Dunya IVF Clinic

PGT-A is designed to enhance embryo selection by detecting chromosomal abnormalities that may hinder the implantation process or lead to miscarriage and genetic disorders. It is estimated that more than 50% of embryos created during IVF cycles have some form of chromosomal abnormality, and this rate is expected to be even higher in women of advanced maternal age (over 35 years old). By screening for these abnormalities, PGT-A helps identify the healthiest embryos for transfer, thus optimizing the chances of achieving a successful pregnancy per embryo transfer.

PGT-A and Its Impact on Pregnancy and Live Birth Rates

Pregnancy Rate per Embryo Transfer: PGT-A can significantly increase the pregnancy rate per embryo transfer by allowing clinicians to select euploid embryos (those with the correct number of chromosomes) for transfer. By focusing on genetically normal embryos, PGT-A enhances the likelihood that the transferred embryo will successfully implant and lead to a pregnancy. This means that for each embryo transfer, the chances of achieving a pregnancy are higher when PGT-A is utilized if indicated.

Cumulative Live Birth Rates: While PGT-A improves the pregnancy rate per embryo transfer, it does not necessarily increase cumulative live birth rates over multiple IVF cycles. Cumulative live birth rates refer to the overall probability of achieving at least one live birth after a series of IVF attempts, considering all embryos transferred across those cycles. Although selecting euploid embryos can enhance the success of individual transfers, the total number of embryos available and the overall success of multiple IVF cycles may not see a significant increase due to factors such as the availability of viable embryos and the potential for miscarriages in subsequent cycles.

Detection vs. Correction of Genetic Abnormalities: PGT-A is designed to detect chromosomal abnormalities in embryos, allowing for informed decisions about which embryos to transfer. However, it cannot correct any existing genetic abnormalities. If an embryo is found to have chromosomal abnormalities through PGT-A, it can be excluded from transfer, but there is no current technology available that can correct these abnormalities within embryos. Therefore, PGT-A serves as a screening tool rather than a therapeutic intervention for genetic issues.

In summary, PGT-A enhances the likelihood of pregnancy for each embryo transferred but does not improve the overall cumulative live birth rates across multiple cycles. Additionally, while it can identify chromosomal abnormalities in embryos, it cannot correct these abnormalities.

Answer from the fertility expert:
Cynthia Caliccio

Yes, Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A) has been proposed as a tool that could potentially increase the success rates of in vitro fertilization (IVF). PGT-A allows the identification of embryos with an abnormal number of chromosomes (aneuploidies) before they are transferred to the uterus. The goal is to improve implantation rates and reduce the risk of miscarriage, especially in cases where chromosomal abnormalities are more likely to occur.

When reviewing the scientific evidence available, the potential benefits of PGT-A in IVF can be summarized as follows:

  1. Selection of genetically normal embryos: PGT-A enables the selection of euploid embryos, meaning embryos that have the correct number of chromosomes. By transferring only genetically normal embryos, there is a greater likelihood of implanting viable and healthy embryos, which can increase the chances of a successful pregnancy.
  2. Reduction in miscarriages: Early miscarriages are frequently caused by chromosomal abnormalities such as aneuploidies. By identifying and avoiding the transfer of embryos with these abnormalities, PGT-A can potentially reduce the likelihood of miscarriage.
  3. Fewer failed transfers: By minimizing the transfer of aneuploid embryos, the number of failed implantation attempts can be reduced. This means fewer cycles where the embryo fails to implant, which can be emotionally and financially beneficial for patients.
  4. Improve clinical pregnancy rates: Certain studies suggest that PGT-A may increase clinical pregnancy rates, particularly in groups of patients at higher risk of chromosomal abnormalities, such as women over the age of 35 or those with repeated IVF failures.

    There are several important factors to consider when evaluating PGT-A.

      • Maternal age: As women age, the likelihood of aneuploidies in embryos increases. Therefore, PGT-A may be more beneficial for older women. Evidence has shown that the positive effects of PGT-A are more pronounced in women over 35. For younger women under 35, the benefit may not be as significant, given the lower incidence of aneuploidies in this age group.
      • Cost: The use of PGT-A adds substantial costs to the overall IVF process, as it requires additional procedures such as embryo biopsies and genetic testing. This increased cost may not be feasible for all patients.

    While some studies have demonstrated improved implantation rates and reduced miscarriage rates with PGT-A, other research has not shown a significant improvement in live birth rates, particularly in younger women with a good ovarian reserve.

    In conclusion, PGT-A may improve the success rates of IVF in certain groups, especially those at higher risk for chromosomal abnormalities, such as women over 35 or those with recurrent IVF failures. However, it is not a guaranteed solution for all patients and should be considered based on individual circumstances.

Answer from the fertility expert:
Maria José Mendiola, Gynaecologist in Reproductive Medicine & Reproductive Genetics, Clínica Monterrico
Answer from the fertility expert:
Dimitra Christopikou, Head of the PGT lab, Embryogenesis IVF Unit Athens

This is a very debatable area for the past 30 years. The debate is upon the use and whether this add on to the IVF procedure really helps increase the IVF success rate and whether the embryo genetic diagnosis is one 100% accurate. What we know so far for the meta analysis and research, is that it is not a 100% percent accurate screening test, it has a percentage of false positive and negative results so it has a percentage of misdiagnosis. It also has been shown that it does not increase the cumulative live birth rates. So it might increase the chances of having a baby earlier and not having a miscarriage during your IVF process. However it does not increase the cumulative birth rate. 

Answer from the fertility expert:
Luca Gianaroli, Scientific Director, S.I.S.Me.R.

The diagnosis doesn’t increase the quality of the genetic material. It only suggests a recommendation to the clinical staff not to transfer the embryos with no possibility of developing into a normal pregnancy.

Removing those embryos from the reproductive circuit that are chromosomally abnormal reduces the time to achieve pregnancy for a couple. We can help them make a final diagnosis for which maybe if the couple continues to use their own gametes, they will not get a full-term pregnancy.

The diagnosis could be useful for the couple. Sometimes couples that have failed many times want to have an answer. The answer is most possibly positive with the pregnancy or negative answers saying this gamete will never develop into a pregnancy. So other routes are to be found to look for a full-term pregnancy; it could be a sperm donation or oocyte donation, adoption or stopping looking for a baby.

Answer from the fertility expert:
Maria Arquè, Reproductive Specialist

Pre-Implantation Genetic Screening (or testing) is a procedure that checks whether an embryo is euploid – that is, whether it has the correct number of chromosomes. The results of this test tell us which embryos are the best candidates for a transfer. Only transferring embryos that we know are chromosomally normal gives us higher chances of success.

On its own, PGS does not improve pregnancy chances during a cycle, as pregnancy depends on more factors than just embryo quality. However, pregnancy rates are higher, and the likelihood of miscarriage is lower when euploid embryos are transferred. Genetically imperfect embryos are one of the most common causes of pregnancy loss. The time to pregnancy also decreases through PGS testing, as we’re eliminating the possibility of transferring aneuploid embryos.

Answer from the fertility expert:
Ester Padilla Ruiz, IVF-Life Group

PGS is the old name for the technique now called PGT-A (Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Aneuploidies). It can increase IVF success rates, especially in patients with a history of failed treatments. It is not a way of improving embryo quality, however. All it allows us to do is to discard those embryos, which have chromosomal abnormalities – as a result, we only transfer healthy embryos. Because of this, we reduce the number of transfers, the chance of miscarriage, the time to pregnancy, and costs for IVF patients, while simultaneously increasing the chances of a healthy pregnancy.

We evaluate developing embryos by checking several parameters. The quality of the embryo is initially judged only by a morphological assessment, not a genetic one; only PGT, however, can give us the full picture of an embryo’s health.

There is an established link between a woman’s age and the ratio of aneuploid embryos eggs result in; this, in turn, leads to a decline in overall fertility. Even in egg donors, up to 35% of generated blastocysts could carry genetic defects. The reason for that is cell division – that is, in women of advanced maternal age, eggs are less likely to undergo correct division, leading to cells with an incorrect distribution of chromosomes. Embryos generated from oocytes of women in advanced maternal age are more likely to have chromosomal abnormalities, even if morphologically they look healthy; as such, the only way to detect truly healthy embryos is PGT.

IVF failure can also be caused by the male factor. Although problems with the male factor usually cause problems, such as fertilization failure or the arrest of embryo development, the sperm can also carry aneuploidies, structural chromosome abnormalities, meiotic defects, and others. The bottom line is PGT can increase IVF success rates by helping fertility specialists only transfer genetically normal embryos, which have a greater chance to result in a healthy pregnancy.

Answer from the fertility expert:
Victoria Walker, Fertility Specialist, Institut Marquès

If you have two embryos – one that has been biopsied and is known to be genetically normal, and another, which has the same morphological quality (and we can tell it’s genetically normal even without a biopsy, due to the way it developed), then these two embryos have the same chance of implanting. Thus, the biopsy itself doesn’t increase the implantation chance, but it also doesn’t reduce it.

The important concept is whether the embryo looks normal when examined under a microscope; at the moment, we can’t tell whether it’s genetically normal simply by examining it visually. Women under 35 have a high chance of producing genetically normal embryos; that chance goes down with age. The probability of producing genetically abnormal embryos can also be increased with ovarian stimulation; that probability can also be profoundly affected by male factor infertility.

PGS identifies the genetically normal embryo; in that way, it has been shown to change three things: it can decrease the number of embryo transfers needed to create an ongoing pregnancy, decrease the time needed to establish a healthy pregnancy, and it can also reduce the risk of miscarriage.

To answer the question, does PGS increase the success rates in IVF, the answer is both yes and no. For an individual patient who requires IVF, PGS can decrease the time it takes to achieve pregnancy, even if the biopsy itself doesn’t increase the chances of the embryo implanting compared to one that hasn’t been biopsied.

Can embryo biopsy damage the embryo?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

Read More »

What is the PGT-A strategy for patients with implantation failure?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

Read More »

On what day are embryos biopsied for PGT-A?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

Read More »

How can PGT-A reduce the time to pregnancy?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

Read More »

How can PGT-A improve embryo selection?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

Read More »

Can I see results – report from PGT-A / PGS tests?

Dimitra Christopikou, Clinical Laboratory Geneticist
Geneticist

Read More »

Can I use PGT-A / PGS for gender selection?

Nurit Winkler,
Gynaecologist

+ 1 more answers

Read More »

Can PGT-A / PGS detect autism?

Maria José Mendiola, MD, MSc in Human Genetics, MSc in Science Communication, ObGyn
Gynaecologist

+ 1 more answers

Read More »

Can you do a fresh embryo transfer with PGT-A / PGS?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

+ 1 more answers

Read More »

Does PGT-A / PGS reduce miscarriage risk?

Dimitra Christopikou, Clinical Laboratory Geneticist
Geneticist

Read More »

How many embryos should you PGT-A / PGS test?

Dimitra Christopikou, Clinical Laboratory Geneticist
Geneticist

Read More »

How many embryos should you have for PGT-A / PGS test?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

+ 1 more answers

Read More »

How many embryos survive PGT-A / PGS testing?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

+ 1 more answers

Read More »

How many PGT-A / PGS normal embryos miscarry?

Dimitra Christopikou, Clinical Laboratory Geneticist
Geneticist

Read More »

What are the pros and cons of using PGT-A / PGS testing on embryos?

Raúl Olivares, MD
Gynaecologist

+ 1 more answers

Read More »

What is the difference between PGS and PGT-A?

Dimitra Christopikou, Clinical Laboratory Geneticist
Geneticist

Read More »

How often do PGT-A / PGS tested embryos fail?

Dimitra Christopikou, Clinical Laboratory Geneticist
Geneticist

Read More »

Can PGT-A / PGS detect gender of an embryo?

Nurit Winkler,
Gynaecologist

+ 1 more answers

Read More »

How much does PGT A PGS testing cost?

Maria José Mendiola, MD, MSc in Human Genetics, MSc in Science Communication, ObGyn
Gynaecologist

+ 1 more answers

Read More »

Should PGT-A / PGS be used to test embryos developed from donor’s eggs?

Halyna Strelko, MD
Gynaecologist

+ 2 more answers

Read More »

What percentage of embryos pass PGT-A / PGS testing?

Dimitra Christopikou, Clinical Laboratory Geneticist
Geneticist

Read More »

Why do PGT-A / PGS embryos fail?

Dimitra Christopikou, Clinical Laboratory Geneticist
Geneticist

Read More »

Can you avoid Down syndrome with IVF?

Glykeria Samolada, Biologisst, MSc. Mol. Cytogenetics
Geneticist

+ 4 more answers

Read More »

How accurate is PGT-A/PGS?

Maria José Mendiola, MD, MSc in Human Genetics, MSc in Science Communication, ObGyn
Gynaecologist

+ 3 more answers

Read More »

Should I transfer 1 or 2 embryos after PGS?

Maria José Mendiola, MD, MSc in Human Genetics, MSc in Science Communication, ObGyn
Gynaecologist

+ 3 more answers

Read More »