Is my endometrium well prepared for an embryo transfer?

Elena Santiago, MD
Fertility Specialist at Clinica Tambre, Clinica Tambre

Category:
Embryo Implantation, Embryo Transfer, IVF process

From this video you will find out:

What do the endometrial preparations include?
What are the requirements for fresh embryo transfer?
How do you prepare the endometrial lining for frozen embryo transfer?
What tests can be performed to increase the chance of successful embryo transfer?
What is the ERA test, and how does it work?
What are EMMA/ALICE/ META tests?

Is my endometrium well prepared for an embryo transfer?

How to improve your endometrium lining to prepare for IVF?

In this webinar session, Dr Elena Santiago, Fertility Specialist at Clinica Tambre, Madrid, explained what tests can be performed and what can be improved to increase the chances of successful embryo transfer. Dr Elena Santiago started her presentation by explaining what she’d like to discuss during this webinar. She started with the definition of the endometrium. After that, she focused on different types of preparation for fresh embryo transfers and frozen embryo transfers. She finished by explaining the meaning of endometrial tests that can be done to see when it’s indicated or not.

The endometrium – definition

The endometrium is a tissue that we have inside the uterus, it is the innermost layer where the embryo implantation and the fetus development take place. This tissue is special in women’s organisms because it changes depending on the timing of the ovarian cycle. So there are different moments where we get different types of the endometrium, but everything is thought so that we can get pregnant. Due to the ovarian hormones produced during a natural cycle, the endometrium is changing. First, the oestrogens are the highest levels of hormones, and they help the lining to thicken for a potential pregnancy. Afterwards, we also need progesterone, which is produced after ovulation, and this hormone helps supply the lining and stimulates the glands to grow and nourish the early embryo. This is a very important part of a woman’s organism during her fertility treatment. There are different ways in which we can prepare the endometrium for an embryo transfer.

Endometrial preparation

We can prepare the endometrium for a fresh embryo transfer during an IVF and for a frozen embryo transfer, in which there are 2 basic options of preparation. It can be during a substituted cycle with hormonal treatment, or sometimes we can also do a natural modified cycle.

Fresh embryo transfer – preparations

What are the requirements for a fresh embryo transfer to take place?

3 layer endometrium, more than 7 millimetres of thickness
blood progesterone levels, less than 1 ng /ml the day of the trigger (if they are higher, it means that the window of implantation could be affected, and therefore, it’s not good to go ahead with fresh embryo transfer)
no risk of having a Hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS)

We shouldn’t proceed with fresh embryo transfer if, for example, we’ve been having loads of follicles growing during the simulations, more than 15 follicles of 16 millimetres on the day of the trigger, it’s better to freeze the embryo and do a transfer later on so that we don’t get that risk of hyperstimulation syndrome. Also, hormones are going to help us to know if there is an added risk. So not only we are going to see the progesterone levels, but also the estrogen levels. If they are higher than 2,500 or 3000 pg/ml, it means that probably that woman has quite a risk of developing an OHSS syndrome afterwards when she gets pregnant, if the embryo implants. Finally, we have to check the number of eggs that we retrieved because if we have more than 15 eggs, it’s better to freeze the embryo and go ahead with an embryo transfer at another cycle so that we get rid of the risk of OHSS.

Frozen embryo transfer – preparations

Nowadays, frozen embryo transfers are much more common than fresh embryo transfers. We are using PGT-A testing on the embryos, therefore, we need to freeze the embryos after the biopsy, so that we can wait for the results. There are different ways of preparing the endometrium.

Substituted cycle

The first option will be with a substituted cycle. It’s the most common preparation used because it’s easier to plan, and we need fewer ultrasounds during the preparation. We start with the oestrogens’ treatment from the start of a cycle, and this medication can be taken orally, transdermal with patches or creams or even vaginally. How does it work?

1st ultrasound at the start of the cycle (on the 2nd or 3rd day of the period to check if the ovaries are resting and that the endometrium is quite thin)
start with oestrogens
2nd ultrasound to check the endometrial lining (a 3-layer of more than 7 millimetres of thickness) and check the progesterone level (lower than 1 ng/ml)
add progesterone 5 days before the transfer (vaginally – 400 mg/ 12h) or subcutaneous progesterone (25 mg/12h)

If we are using the vaginal progesterone, it’s important that 1-to 2 days before doing the transfer, we check the progesterone levels again to see if they are correct. A lot of patients can get under 10 mg/ml levels of progesterone, which is considered not enough for proper embryo implantation or a developing pregnancy. Therefore, if we don’t have at least 10 ng/ml, we add subcutaneous progesterone to the vaginal one so that we are sure that our levels are going to be correct in a modified cycle. 2. Natural modified cycle The steps in a natural modified cycle:

the ultrasound, but from the 7th-8th day of the cycle onwards (each 48h-36h)
a 3-layer endometrium of more than 7 millimetres, and the dominant follicle, have to be at least 16 mm so that we can schedule the transfer.
hCG to produce ovulation and 7 days after the embryo transfer
add progesterone 5 days before the transfer (if it’s vaginally, it is 400 mg//12h, every 12 hours, or subcutaneous progesterone 25 mg/24

The ovaries are also producing the progesterone on their own, so there is no reason to test progesterone levels with this type of protocol.

The pros & cons of using the natural modified cycle:

The pros are that we are going to use less medication, and oestrogens are not needed at this point, therefore, without the oestrogens, we can have fewer side effects. It also has its cons, we can only use it in women with regular cycles. We are going to have less planification, which means the transfer will need to be scheduled. We also need to do more ultrasounds to follow up on the natural cycle, and there is more probability of cancellation due to spontaneous ovulation.

Endometrial tests

The endometrial tests are not necessarily done on every patient. It depends on the case, but some options allow us to look at the endometrium a bit more and have more information.

Endometrial receptivity (ERA, TIME tests)

The window of implantation is known as the period when the endometrium has the best conditions for the embryo implantation to occur. We say that the endometrium is receptive at that point. Normally, it lasts for around 3 days only. It should be more or less the same for each woman, but lots of research and lots of DNA testing of the endometrium showed that around 30% of the patients have a different window of implantation. Therefore, they will need to change their preparation protocol. There are several tests that we can use. One of them is called the ERA test. Another one is called the TIME test. Both of them do the testing of numerous genes to see if the endometrium is at the point when we are doing the biopsy. If it is at the point, that means it is receptive. We do preparation, no matter what type of protocol we use, but when we are going to do the embryo transfer, we are doing an endometrial biopsy, which is normally done at the consultation. Several days after, we get the results to see if this woman is receptive at that point, or if we need any changes in the protocol of preparations. What are the indications for these tests?

patients with several unsuccessful good quality embryo transfers
patients with previous unsuccessful normal embryo transfer
patients who want. to have a better approach to their endometrium before transferring their embryos

Endometrial microbiome (EMMA, ALICE, META tests)

We can do those tests at the same time as the endometrial biopsy. EMMA, ALICE and META tests are used to look at the microorganisms that we have inside the endometrium. It’s normal to have bacteria over there, but the normal bacteria that we require for implantation to take place and developing pregnancy to take place is called the Lactobacilli species. There are other good bacteria species there, but this is the basic one. There could be pathogenic deviations in the dominant microbiome. If we don’t have that normal level of Lactobacilli required, the normal is more than 90% of this type of activity, we could have some infertility problems such as implantation failure or miscarriages. We can check this, it’s a DNA study of the bacteria we have inside our endometrium. On the graph shown, in a patient with ongoing pregnancies, the population of Lactobacilli is completely dominant over the rest of the bacteria. In patients with recurrent miscarriages or implantation failures, there is also that type of bacteria, but other bacteria are coming out as the result of the DNA testing. It’s not only going to tell us if our microbiome is fine, the same biopsy is going to tell us if there are any pathogens or bad bacteria that could be causing chronic endometritis. This is an infection that could be long term inflammation of the endometrium that doesn’t give any symptoms. If this occurs, we need to start an antibiotic treatment to try to stop the infection or inflammation. When do we consider that we need to look at the microbiome?

implantation failure
recurrent miscarriages
anyone who wants to have a better approach to the endometrium before the transfer
thin endometrial lining

Take-home messages

The endometrium is extremely important for fertility treatments. A good endometrium may increase the implantation rates. Apart from the basic examination regarding the lining of the thickness, we also have several endometrial tests that we can do to have much more information rather than only the ultrasound image. The main goal is to improve reproductive outcomes.

How to improve your endometrium lining to prepare for IVF? - Questions and Answers

Is the level of serum progesterone indicative of uterus progesterone levels? I tested my levels before and after the frozen transfer, and the level dropped significantly, despite progesterone pessaries and injections, would this be normal, or you would expect the level to be stable and continue to rise rather than drop? I had a chemical loss on that occasion. My progesterone level 1 day after the transfer was 43. 22 ng/ml, and then 3 days later, it was 38.7 mol/L.

It’s not something that needs to be increasing all the time. Normally, it’s something that should be more or less stable from the moment you started the progesterone supplements in 24 hours if you are taking the same medication, it should be stable. We have to take into account where you’ve done the tests because if you do them at a different lab, you can get different results. The evidence says that we have to check blood levels to assume that we are having correct levels for embryo transfer, and therefore, implantation to take place. If you have less than 10 ng/ml of progesterone level in your blood after at least 24 hours of your treatment, then go ahead and put subcutaneous progesterone. However, normally with that added progesterone to the pessaries, it should be enough. If you have more than 10 ng/ml, it should be enough. You also have to take into account the time you are doing those blood tests, it may vary on the time of the day as well.

Do you recommend progesterone injections daily or twice weekly?

There are different types of progesterone. Normally, the subcutaneous ones are daily. It should be 1 or 2 shots per day, depending on the protocol, or if we are adding it up to the vaginal progesterone, normally twice a week. It’s another type of medication, it’s intramuscular progesterone. That’s why the protocol is different, too. At first, intramuscular progesterone is valid, but it is not something we use a lot in Spain. That’s why, I didn’t mention it, but I know that in other countries, such as the US, they use it a lot. You can get very good levels of progesterone with a protocol, even if it is only twice-weekly.

I am having my 3rd IVF cycle. I have had a mild/mini-cycle, with 1 fertilized egg. All my cycles have resulted in 1 egg retrieved, and the rest have been empty follicles. In the last cycle, we had an embryo transfer, but it was too painful vaginally. In this third round, they were unable to access my ovaries as my fibroid has grown and gone through my stomach. This seems to have gotten bigger since starting IVF due to medications, it is 12cm, and it’s on the left outer uterus. I hope I will get an embryo transfer in a few days, I’m currently on 800 mg of progesterone. Can this fibroid affect my chances?

It’s difficult to advise with the information I have here. If the fibroid is not affecting the endometrium, maybe it’s not at a point of the uterus where it could affect the egg retrieval to take place vaginally, and that could happen. If it’s not very big, and it’s intramuscular, that shouldn’t be affecting the chances of implantation. There are too many things that have to be considered in your case. I don’t have all the information to be confident in telling you that it doesn’t affect it.

I have 6, day-3 frozen embryos. These are the only embryos we have, it took us several IVF cycles to accumulate these 6 embryos. My embryologists just advised freezing on day-3 because we only had a few, so we want to give them the best chance. Three of these embryos are top quality, and the other 3 are good to fair quality. How do you recommend proceeding with the transfer? Two at a time and starting with the best? I am a bit worried about not losing both of them if there would be an issue occurring after the transfer, maybe with the endometrium?

The endometrium needs to be checked before embryo transfer, that is for sure. It shouldn’t be something that we find afterwards. If you want to be confident about your endometrium, I do advise you to do the tests we were talking about before going for the frozen embryo transfer. As they are day-3 embryos, normally to have maximum chances per embryo transfer, it is better to put 2 together. It depends on your medical conditions, if you have any problems, your age, this is something to be considered by your doctor because by putting 2, we do increase a bit the risk of twins, and this is something that needs to be considered. In terms of lower chances, it’s better to transfer 2 by 2, and normally protocols will be to go first with the 2 best ones, then decrease all the quality for each embryo transfer. It doesn’t mean that the best ones are going to the implant for sure, and the other ones won’t. It’s a way of selecting embryos in order.

How do you most effect effectively treat low levels of Lactobasilicus?

The most effective way is to use Lactobacillus probiotics directly with vaginal pessaries of these probiotics. There are concrete preparations that they sell at the pharmacies or even online. You can get them, sometimes, it’s not a medication itself. It’s better if those probiotics are vaginally rather than orally.

What are your thoughts on having endometrial scratch as part of the preparation?

I didn’t mention that because there is not enough evidence to prove that it is going to improve or give better chances of implantation. It’s not something that we normally do. If your gynaecologist suggests using it, just to do something else or something different, it’s not so invasive, so why not try that. For me, it’s much more valid doing the endometrial tests that we’ve talked about because we will have much more information with that rather than scratching. Taking into the account that if you do an endometrial biopsy, the cycle previous to the endometrial preparation, you are also doing a scratching. It’s absolutely the same. The endometrial biopsy itself is doing a scratching in the endometrium, but I don’t think that this is the reason outcomes may improve after doing the endometrial testing.

Apart from progesterone and estrogen, what supplements help to thicken the lining for frozen embryo transfer?

Normally, this is the basic treatment, but to thicken the lining in women who don’t respond to this treatment, sometimes we have to use other types of medication such as vitamins, for example, vitamin E, and aspirin. Other times, maybe if the woman has regular cycles, we can use gonadotropins as if we were doing an ovarian stimulation instead of putting oestrogens. There are different options depending on each patient, but let’s say that the basic one is the one that we’ve talked about.

What supplements increase blood flow to the uterus?

The supplements that increase blood flow to the uterus are vitamin E or aspirin, anti-clotting, let’s say treatments, but it’s not always considered to be useful in every patient. It depends, on each case.

Do you think recurrent implantation failure can be due to an autoimmune disease, Psoriatic arthritis & Psoriasis? There appears to be a lot of date diverging opinions on what impacts the immune system can have on implantation/pregnancy?

There are lots of cases where recurrent implantation failure is due to the immune system. It doesn’t have to be related to Psoriatic arthritis & Psoriasis by itself. This depends on each case, but normally it’s true that if you have already an autoimmune disease, you can get some other factors going on during the implantation that could be affecting you. My advice would be, if you have implantation failure in your case, go ahead and have a special consultation with an immunologist, the specialist that will consider all your medical records, see what tests you need to do and see if you need any other medication, add it up to, let’s say the basic protocols that we’ve talked about.

What are your thoughts on EmbryoGlue? Is this a useful tool for implantation?

The scientific evidence doesn’t show significant improvement in pregnancy rates. It’s something that we don’t have the experience with because we decided at a point that we are not going to use it as it doesn’t improve the results.

If you have an ERA test as it’s a mock cycle, is there a chance the actual cycle for transfer may have a slightly different implantation window? There is no way of knowing that each cycle is the same.

The proper labs that do all these endometrial testing will tell you that the window of implantation is going to be the same for each patient. If it takes a long time from when the test was done until the embryo transfer, let’s say several months or years, the window of implantation can be altered. However, it doesn’t mean that it will change from one cycle to another. It’s true that when we’re doing this type of testing, they recommend doing it in a cycle just before the embryo transfer.

I’m in menopause, and I had a fresh transfer 2 years ago, and it was successful. I did a FET 3 weeks ago, and it was unsuccessful. I wanted to ask if the Ovitrel (3 shots) that I used was not in the fridge as it was shipped to me (Israel from the US), and I put it in the fridge after it arrived. I used it after 7 months, but it wasn’t in the fridge again on the plane (the US to Prague), does that play a big factor in unsuccessful FET transfer?

I’m not sure if that would cause non-implantation. All the factors count, but it doesn’t mean that if the medication wasn’t in the fridge, it doesn’t work for sure. Many other factors interfere with the implantation, so I can’t tell you it was the cause.

I just got a negative result after FET. Everything was good, but I have a 6.5 cm subserosal fibroid. My doctor thinks it might have caused the loss and recommended a myomectomy. What do you advise?

It all depends on the location of this fibroid. If it is subserosal, it means it is outside the part of the uterus, and these types of fibroid shouldn’t affect the implantation unless there is more than 50% of that fibroid affecting the muscle of the uterus.

I have done embryo hatching due to low AMH & ovarian reserve. We have now 7 day-5 blastocysts frozen after 10 egg collections in total. We haven’t tested our blastocysts as we only made 1 blastocyst on each round. We did FET of 2 blastocysts last year, and I had my 1st pregnancy ever, but it ended in biochemical. We did immunology tests which showed slightly raised NK cells. We are now waiting for 3 months to get in shape mentally & physically and then will do FET in August. Would you recommend transferring 2 as I will be 43 in September, also what is your opinion on IVIG/intralipids/ prednisone and if I should do ERA/ALICE/EMMA?

I don’t believe that double embryo transfer is going to help you. If you’re having an embryo at the blastocyst stage of good quality, I do recommend doing a single embryo transfer. Double embryo transfer is not going to increase your chances. On the other hand, it will increase the risk of having twins, which can create and increase the risks of other problems. If your doctor suggests IVIG, intralipids or prednisone in your particular case, then go ahead. It’s very difficult to scientifically prove that these work, but if there is any indication, it is better to use them rather than not. Regarding the ERA/EMMA/ALICE tests, I think that those are easy to perform before the other embryo transfer, I do recommend them as they will give you more information before the transfer.

Have you seen any endometrium differences in both age and BMI?

Normally, age is not something that makes the endometrial preparation more difficult to take place. I don’t think it is something that could affect the endometrium. Menopausal women indeed have less blood flow in the uterus, and it is more difficult, but it is not the cause. Regarding BMI, it could influence the proper effect of the medication we’re giving, and it may not work as good. The problem appears to impact the implantation rates and developing pregnancy rather than endometrial preparation.

I did ERA/EMMA/ALICE, and all was normal except lactobacillus – the bacteria was not different from the water solution, so very low level. You mentioned that a low level can cause implantation failure or miscarriage, would this happen very quickly after implantation or in later weeks?

It depends, I don’t know when it could occur. If you have a low level of lactobacillus, it could not only affect the implantation but also can increase the miscarriage rates. It would normally be a miscarriage during the 1st trimester.

Both endometrial tests require biopsy, so a mock cycle? Would you recommend both of these tests?

When we’re doing the window of implantation check-up, we always need to do a mock cycle. For EMMA/ALICE/META tests, we don’t need a mock cycle if we’re not adding the ERA/TIME tests.

I am 33 and have premature ovarian insufficiency. I just had a cancelled round of IVF due to no follicles maturing. Would you have any advice for the endometrium preparation for my particular case? My clinic will not try to retrieve more eggs. The next plan is to unfreeze 2 eggs to form the embryos for the transfer.

Even if you have premature ovarian insufficiency, it doesn’t mean that your endometrium won’t be well-prepared. If you’re not having regular cycles right now, I recommend going ahead with a substituted cycle, so adding oestrogens from the beginning. It can work the same way even if you’re not having periods.

In terms of the success rate of an embryo transfer, what percentage would you give the role of the endometrium and the embryos?

It’s very difficult to give a percentage as it all depends on the woman’s age, the quality of the embryos etc. However, in general, the embryo and the endometrium are the most important factors.

What are your thoughts on downregulation injections such as Prostap as part of preparation? Would a patient’s age influence this decision?

That is not something that we normally use. I supposed it is another option, but I am not used to doing this type of preparation, so it is hard for me to advise on that.

For how long do we have to try to prepare the endometrium in FET? Is the E2 still low?

Let’s say that the preparation will take around 3 weeks in total, but it shouldn’t take more than 4-5 weeks. You can try to add more medication if you see that after 10 days after taking medication, the endometrium is not thick enough, then do another check-up a week after that. If nothing happens, it’s better to cancel it and start over again rather than go for a longer treatment.

Have you heard of someone going straight to IVF and not starting with IUI? My doctor told me that it would be best to start with IUI (I am in my early 40s).

I have lots of patients that go straight for IVF without doing IUI, it depends on each case. In my opinion, if you are over 38 and go directly for IVF, you will have a much higher chance of success, rather than doing IUI cycles. The time is crucial, and I also have patients that go straight to egg donation because of age, maybe it is not your case, but I suggest going for IVF directly.

Implantation Failure in IVF – Why does it happen and how to prevent it?

The effect of endometriosis and its IVF/ICSI outcome?

Add-ons (Time-lapse, MACS, EmbryoGlue, etc.). What you need to ask about additional treatments?

Success case study: repeated miscarriages

Main factors of egg donation failure and what to do to overcome this?

What do you need to know before embarking on your IVF journey?

Authors

Elena Santiago, MD

Dr. Elena Santiago is a Specialist in Fertility. She obtained her Degree in Medicine and Surgery at Universidad Autónoma de Madrid and she was a Residential Doctor of Gynaecology and Obstetrics at Severo Ochoa University Hospital, also located in Madrid. Dr. Santiago also holds a Masters in Human Reproduction from the Universidad Rey Juan Carlos in Madrid, and she is currently one of the members of the Tambre medical team. Those who have been with her in the consultation room highlight the doctor's kindness, her eagerness to personalise each patient's case and her professionalism. Dr. Santiago speaks fluent Spanish, English and French.

Event Moderator

Caroline Kulczycka

Caroline Kulczycka is managing MyIVFAnswers.com and has been hosting IVFWEBINARS dedicated to patients struggling with infertility since 2020. She's highly motivated and believes that educating patients so that they can make informed decisions is essential in their IVF journey. In the past, she has been working as an International Patient Coordinator, where she was helping and directing patients on their right path. She also worked in the tourism industry, and dealt with international customers on a daily basis, including working abroad. In her free time, you’ll find her travelling, biking, learning new things, or spending time outdoors.

Cookie	Duration	Description
_ga	2 years	This cookie is installed by Google Analytics. The cookie is used to calculate visitor, session, campaign data and keep track of site usage for the site's analytics report. The cookies store information anonymously and assign a randomly generated number to identify unique visitors.
_gat_UA-38575237-21	1 minute	No description
_gid	1 day	This cookie is installed by Google Analytics. The cookie is used to store information of how visitors use a website and helps in creating an analytics report of how the website is doing. The data collected including the number visitors, the source where they have come from, and the pages visted in an anonymous form.

Cookie	Duration	Description
_gat_FSQM52	1 minute	No description
cf_ob_info		No description
cf_use_ob		No description